Filters

EVENTS

12.04.26

Handel’s Messiah Part III: I Know That My Redeemer Liveth, an Online Event with Mia Chung & Richard Westerfield

As we begin Advent, we’ll explore the third and final part of George Frideric Handel’s Messiah. Our guides are concert pianist and Trinity Forum Senior…
Learn More
12.07.26

A Christmas Concert with Sara Groves

Sara’s music invites us to bring our joys and longings into the story of Christmas, and to discover fresh hope in the promise of God…
Learn More

Trinity Forum Membership

Join or Renew Your Trinity Forum Membership

GIVE

Give a One-Time Gift or Explore Planned Giving

The President’s Circle

Become a Leading Supporter of the Trinity Forum

Sponsorships

Sponsor a Conversation, Podcast, or Reading

Good News About Shame, with Toni Kim

August 21, 2026 1:30pm - 2:30pm ET
Overview

How have we been shaped by our shame-oriented culture? We, and those we love, are buffeted by shame coming from both our consciences and an unforgiving culture. How does Christian wisdom guide us to an appropriate perspective on shame?

In her new book, Shame Redeemed: Learning to Live in Christ’s Freedom, Toni Kim provides wisdom for navigating the shame. She explores the full complexity of shame in the Bible, including its relationship to sin and guilt, the danger of shamelessness, and spiritual practices to help God’s liberating truth sink in.

Join us for an online conversation with Toni Kim on Friday, August 21 at 1:30pm ET.

Special thanks to our co-hosts National Association of Evangelicals and InterVarsity Press

Speakers

  • Cherie Harder
  • Toni Kim
Transcript
CHERIE HARDER:

We live in a time of widespread public shaming and call out and cancel culture, where mistakes or even misunderstandings are weaponized to destroy reputations. So it’s easy to understand how easy it is to feel disoriented and discouraged, preoccupied with image, or unsure of what it means to belong, to be known and loved, to forgive, and to reconcile. But our guest today says that there is good news, that while many Christians have understood the gospel primarily as God’s answer to guilt, we’ve not fully wrestled with the implications, the wonderful implications to the gospel’s answer to shame. She claims that the good news about shame is that just as guilt can be forgiven, shame can be redeemed, and that there’s new identity, transformation, and healing in learning to live in the freedom of Christ. Toni Kim serves as the director of Spiritual care for the National Associations. After previously serving for nearly two decades as a minister at Park Street Congregational Church in downtown Boston, where she helped found, among other things, the Disabilities Ministry, Enable Boston. She is the author of this new work released just this month, Redeeming Shame, which we are so excited to welcome her here today to discuss. Toni, welcome.

TONI KIM:

Oh Cherie, thank you so much for having me.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah, I am really looking forward to it. It’s great to have you here, Toni. And I should note that you actually began studying shame decades ago. In fact, I think your master’s thesis was the basis for this book, which was long before it became like the hot topic in psychology, much less theology. So I’m curious, just in starting out, what led you to do so, and what convinced you so long ago that shame was a neglected biblical theme?

TONI KIM:

Great question. Yeah, I’m really indebted to InterVarsity Christian Fellowship because they gather the Asian American students and brought in Asian American leaders and helped us to see that shame is a part of the Asian culture and the Asian American experience, and that our kind of native understanding of shame actually was a gift because we were able to read the Bible through that lens of shame, because the Bible was written to cultures that were steeped in shame and honor. And so, starting in the late 80s, early 90s, we were talking about what does the Bible say about shame and how does that affect how we understand the good news of Jesus? And so I did end up writing my thesis at Regent College in Vancouver about what the Bible says about shame and how that affects Asian American evangelism and spiritual formation. But then over decades of ministry started to see that the issue of shame does not just affect Asian Americans, but affects everybody, and especially now with social media, it is all shame driven. As you said in the introduction, the whole cancel culture is infused with shame and shamelessness.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. Well, really, we’re going to dig into shame and shamelessness in just a second. But first you mentioned basically your own Asian American upbringing as being one that was more steeped in shame. And in the book, you contrast that upbringing to the more individualistic, American Western society. I would love to hear you sort of talk a little bit more about that because, as you’ve noted, as others have noted, shame is not only personal, it is certainly deeply personal, but there’s also, I mean, it is communal and relational. What was it or what was sort of additional context or knowledge about shame have you gained from your own background and context, which was a more communal society than our highly individualistic American culture?

TONI KIM:

That’s right. Such a good question. And at Regent, again, one of the things we talked about was what does it mean to bear the image of God? And so much of it, because of Augustine, we think about it’s because we’re rational beings. And I think in American culture, the whole individualistic bent is very much focused on the rational part of who we are as humans. But part of what it means to be human is that we are relational beings. So we are both rational and relational. And that communal aspect is something that Asian cultures are very strong in, of understanding that our identity is tied with the relationships that we have. And again, that’s the way the biblical cultures are. And so being able to understand that there is a collective nature to our identity. And it is definitely true for the Western culture and even the American culture. And the American South is very much a shame, honor based culture. I now live in Charlottesville, Virginia and have seen that in, in vivid colors the nine years we’ve been here. But in the social media now we project this image of who we want to be, but we know we aren’t. And so then we feel shame between the distance between who we pretend to be and who we actually are. And then we see our friends doing things that they post about and we weren’t invited. And so we feel shame for being not included. And then if we make one small mistake, we’re afraid it’s going to be broadcast all over and we will be devastated by that shame.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. You mentioned, the highly rationalistic society. And it does seem like the South is much more kind of shame and honor. But so much of American society, I think is probably fairly characterized as more about guilt versus shame. And that tends to track with the rationalistic side that you’ve mentioned. And you wrote before that, I thought it was such a fascinating point, that many Christians understand the gospel primarily, if not almost entirely, through the lens of guilt, but not through the lens of shame. Or they tend to conflate the two. And so I’d love to hear you, your thoughts, maybe to tease out what the distinctions between guilt and shame are and what the consequences are if we either ignore shame or kind of conflate shame with guilt in terms of how we see and understand the gospel.

TONI KIM:

Great question. I think one of the things that grieves God’s heart the most is that the survivor of abuse usually feels shame when the perpetrator feels neither guilt nor shame. So the survivor has a shame problem caused by somebody else’s guilt. When you think only in terms of a guilt rubric, the council becomes, oh, the survivor needs to forgive the person who did this against her. Which, yeah, is something that she will need to work through, but isn’t her core problem. Her core problem is that she feels shame because of what, what has happened to her. And so we need a good news that is going to address the shame that she experiences. Not to say, oh, you shouldn’t feel it. Like, no, she does feel it because she has been tainted or affected by someone else’s guilt. But the good news is that we serve a God who doesn’t just say, oh, don’t feel this way. But who actually entered into shame himself. Jesus was fully God and yet he became human. And as a human he was mocked. He was tortured. He was crucified. He was killed. And so he suffered shame and experienced it. So he understands the shame of the survivor. And then he rose from the dead. And he conquered sin. He conquered guilt. He conquered shame.

TONI KIM:

And he has given us this resurrection life. And we can skip ahead to the end of the Bible in revelation. John has an amazing, he’s taken to the throne room of heaven and he’s about to see, he’s weeping because no one is worthy to open the scroll. And and he’s told, hey, don’t worry, the lion of Judah, he can, he is worthy to open the scrolls. And so he looks. And you expect to see this like mighty lion looking as if he’s never been crucified. But instead Revelation 5 says, I looked and I saw the Lamb looking as if it had been slain. He’s like, wait a second. The shame of being slain. God doesn’t pretend like that didn’t happen. It’s there in the very throne room of heaven. And yet the past shame has been redeemed. There’s no sorrow. There’s no pain from that. It is now something that is worthy of all glory. And that’s what God does for us. There are things that cause us shame. We experience shame, but those things are not the end of our story, and they are not the defining part of our story. And what defines us is what God has done for us in Jesus Christ.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. Oh, there’s so many different directions we could go, Toni, with that. But let me ask something, I guess just fairly basic, which is, well, gosh, yeah. Where to even start, you mentioned like the really unhelpful paradox of an abuse victim, someone who has not done anything wrong, feeling shame while the perp feels neither shame nor guilt. And one of the things we know, I mean, Kurt Thompson had written the introduction to your book and Kurt has been a frequent guest here. One of the things that he has mentioned, I think you mentioned in your book as well, is that shame is often felt in the body even before it consciously registers in the mind, and we may even know rationally that, you know, there’s no reason why a victim of, say, sexual abuse should feel shame. And yet that shame is still felt, even if it is consciously and rationally rejected. What would you say to someone who cognitively and rationally knows that they are loved; they are not guilty, they are redeemed, but they still struggle with the feeling of shame?

TONI KIM:

That’s excellent. And it’s because we can’t solve it rationally. It has to be solved relationally. And so, for those who are struggling, we need to be in relationships, not just with God, but with God’s people. And this is where Kurt with his confessional communities are living this out, and this is what small groups in the church should be living out. This is what what marriages and families should be living out. And the church should be a place where we’re able to say, hey, listen, I need help. And so I don’t think we should eliminate shame, but we need to eliminate shame about shame. So don’t let shame isolate yourself, don’t let shame hide you and say, well, I know what they’re going to tell me anyway so there’s no point in disclosing this to someone else. That’s just fear because it takes a risk to share with someone else. But find someone safe to share with and have them help you relationally heal from the shame and not just rationally heal from the shame that you experience.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. I mean, that is such an interesting point that we can’t recover from relational shame without relational healing. But let me ask you about the mechanism of that, because why can’t we solve shame on our own? Like why, you know, you frequently talk about giving voice to shame. What is it about naming shame out loud to God or to other people? What does it do that private reflection can’t?

TONI KIM:

Well, it’s how we image who God is, right? So God made us. And God is father, son, and Holy Spirit. He exists in relationship. He exists in community. And so I, as an individual human, cannot be who I’m supposed to be by myself. I have to be dependent upon God and interdependent with other people. That’s the way we’re designed. And so we can’t just say, I’m going to have the individual relationship with God, that’s going to be private. We are designed to be in community. And so, James 5 says, confess your sins to one another and pray for each other so that you may be healed. And so there’s something that happens when we invite when we take the risk to be vulnerable with a friend and they pray for us, the spirit comes and brings healing in us, through us, among us and through us to others.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. You know, if shame is relational, then presumably it’s very identity based. And you even talked in your book about how guilt tends to be very much more action based. Guilt is about an action, guilt, fierce punishment, and shame is more about who we are and fears exposure or rejection, which is sort of very different mechanisms. Why do you think that the lie of shame that somehow it’s not just our actions that are sinful, but our person that is unworthy seems to be so widespread today? I mean, I think by any measure we are becoming much more of a shame culture, even if we haven’t caught up with that in terms of how we deal with it. But I mean, certainly, you know, social media traffics in shame, but what are your thoughts about why we have become such a deeply shamed, and we can talk about this in a second or two, but as well as shameless culture.

TONI KIM:

Yeah. You know, let me talk about in the church because I think oftentimes we see ourselves as sinners saved by grace, which is who we are. We are sinners. But if the focus is our identity as sinners, then that’s what we reinforce is, oh, we’re such sinners. I think the dominant motif throughout Scripture is that we’re God’s children, that sin and had to be rescued from that. Our base identity is that we’re God’s children. And I think that we have started to mistake the voice of the stranger for the voice of the good shepherd. So Satan is so widely, he disguises himself as an angel of light. And so Satan come with these accusations about, oh, you know, you’re such a bad Christian and you’re such a bad sinner. And we’re like, oh, this is the Holy Spirit. This must be the good shepherd’s voice. And so we amplify that and we’re like, oh yeah, you’re right. I’m such a bad Christian.

TONI KIM:

I’m such a bad, I’m like, hopeless. I’m such a hypocrite. And we curl it upon ourselves and then we let that be the Christian story. And yet that’s not the voice of the good shepherd. So we have to learn to reject those voices. And we actually need to like, extricate them from our souls. They’re very deeply intertwined into our self understanding. So we need to root those things out and replace them with the truth that we are God’s beloved children. Again, it means we still need to repent of our sin and we still need to ask for forgiveness. But the core identity is that we are children, and the voice of the good shepherd will say, hey, you did this wrong and you need to repent. But here is the Savior who forgives you. I am the Savior who forgives you. I am the Savior who will cleanse you. And if we would be shaped by the voice of that good shepherd, we would be shaped completely differently than we are now.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. Thinking of that, one of the most striking parts of your book is the emphasis on not only did Jesus bear our guilt on the cross, but he endured a deeply shame filled death, public humiliation, mockery, rejection, you know, kind of all the elements of shame were there. And one of our earlier guests in this online conversation series was Tom Holland, who in his book Dominion, at the very beginning, discussed how absolutely unprecedented, bizarre, even like shocking to, you know, the ancient culture of the time that it would be to think that God himself would suffer humiliation. Divinity was seen much more as an exercise in power and domination at the time, as opposed to the endurance of persecution. And we’d love for you to talk a little bit more about how the cross itself that which was seen as shocking, weird, even obscene at the time should change the way that we understand our own experience of shame, of exposure or rejection.

TONI KIM:

Yeah. I mean, it changes everything, right? The cross makes the whole world upside down or right side up again. And you’re exactly right that so much of the world outside the church and too much of the world inside the church is all about power and about maximizing power. And that’s a misunderstanding of what true power is and the true power that the God of the universe has and the true power that the God of the universe models for us. And so yeah, the fact that God himself would let himself be shamed in order to restore honor to his people and to redeem for himself a people that is his very own is completely, a reversal of everything. And so that gives us hope that what we endure can also be redeemed and transformed. But the, another part about the cross is, and we often, we focus on what we see with our own eyes, the deep shame and humiliation that Jesus endured upon the cross. And yet Colossians 2 talks about how at the cross that Jesus made a public spectacle of the powers and authorities. And so on in the earthly realms, whether earthly eyes, we see just the shame, the pain, the humiliation that the Savior went through. But in the cosmic realm by this upside down power move, this jujitsu thing, Jesus has instead crucified the powers and authorities. And so we know the end of the story, that the evil that has been done to us, the evil that we have done ourselves, that does not define us, that does not define our fate, but Jesus, his power, his resurrection, his victory is what defines us all.

CHERIE HARDER:

Oh, that’s beautiful. You know, one thing I wanted to ask you about a little bit earlier, you were talking about just our identity and what the implications are: if we see ourselves primarily as sinners versus see ourselves primarily as the children of God. And, you know, one of the things we’ve talked a fair amount about on this, this program is just. Not only were we created as children of God, we were created as like embodied beings. And with being embodied, there’s all kinds of limitations and weaknesses and frailties just kind of baked into that. And you decided to make one of your chapters on essentially limits and shame, you know, you entitled it living with limits. Why is it that our limits seem so connected to a sense of shame, so triggering of a sense of shame? Why do we, it seems like so widespread, experience our limitations as something shameful and to hide, rather than simply being part and parcel of what it means to be human?

TONI KIM:

Yeah. Great question. Thank you for calling that. And I’ll start by saying, you know, and I wrote that chapter because of what I went through and an experienced. We have a daughter with down syndrome and after she was born, I, we didn’t know ahead of time that she was going to have down syndrome. And, she was in the NICU for the first ten days of her life. And my husband, I went to a grocery store and our bagger was a young woman with down syndrome. And I could barely keep it together. And we left the grocery store and I burst into tears and I said, you know, how can it be possible that the highest hope for our daughter is that she’d be a bagger at a grocery store? And I’m really thankful my husband was like, hey, if she’s happy doing that, I’d be fine with that. But I realized that I was not. And here was, you know, I’d been a minister for seven years, something like that. So my theology was orthodox. I said, I knew God loves you no matter what you say or what you do.

TONI KIM:

But when it came to my daughter, I realized, oh no, being a bagger wasn’t good enough. And so that exposed to myself what I really believe that I really actually believed that limits were bad and limits were somehow shameful. Limits were somehow not good enough. And so God had to actually expose what I really believed. So that he could change that. I think so many of us, we would never say oh, people with disabilities are worth less than we are. I hope we don’t say that. But somewhere deep in our recesses, we think that or feel that, which is why we’re so afraid of becoming disabled as we age. Right. But we are, we all have limits. We were created that we were created as creatures, not as God. And so learning what it means to live with joy in the ways that we were created, as with limits, is a gift that we get to explore, again, totally countercultural opposite what the world would say. But more in line with how God has designed us to be.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. You know, in addition to limits, another thing that comes to us all like limits and seems to be very triggering to shame is failure. You know, we fear failure. We certainly don’t want it exposed and yet we’re all going to fail at some point in our life. Are Christians called to fail differently? And if so, what does that look like?

TONI KIM:

I would say Christians get to fail differently. We get to feel differently because our identity is not tied to our successes or our failures. So we get to fail and say, oh, I failed. And we don’t have to hide that. We don’t have to pretend like we didn’t. We can own up to our mistakes and we can repair what we can repair. We can ask for forgiveness for the things that we have done wrong. And so yes, we get to fail differently. But we have to learn how to do that. We have to train each other on ourselves to do that because it doesn’t come naturally to any of us. Christian or not Christian.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. You know, we’ve talked a lot about how shame seems to be increasing just in our current cultural situation. But paradoxically, so does shamelessness, which is, you know, sort of interesting. I mean, along with cancel culture and call out culture and FOMO and, you know, public image, you know, grooming, there also seems to be kind of like a growing audience that essentially cheers those who throw off, you know, any semblance of following basic norms no matter how essential or decent and instead cheer those who kind of seize power or winners. And some of those folks actually talk fairly explicitly about throwing off shame culture. Like if shame is bad, here’s the antidote. We throw it off. You’ve taken a very different view in your book and, unlike some, you’ve argued that some shame is actually very appropriate, right, and even good, and you have drawn a distinction between, both shame and shamelessness by what you called a biblical idea of becoming unashamed. So what does that mean? And what is the distinction between becoming unashamed and the kind of shamelessness that we’re increasingly seeing more of?

TONI KIM:

Yeah. Excellent. Cherie. So shame is so much more complex than it’s being treated, I think because we have such a negative experience of shame, the culture’s response was, well, let’s get rid of all shame. And that leads to exactly what you described this whole shamelessness. And so what I’m going to do whatever I’m going to throw off everything. But sometimes shame is the appropriate response. It is the pain mechanism that says, hey, you’re doing something wrong that needs to be stopped. So you know, pastor so and so who is abusing kids should feel shame. Like the appropriate response is to have shame. And then with that shame to respond to that by repentance and repair. So we need to experience shame when it is appropriate when we have sinned, when we have wronged someone, someone we have hurt, someone when we’ve broken a promise. And so we see this all throughout scriptures. So when God’s people are adulterous, when you know they should only have one God, they’re only supposed to serve God, but they serve lots of gods and they serve themselves. That needs to they should feel ashamed of that. And so that’s why God brought them through the shame of the exile, because they needed to understand there is such a thing as sin and shame and guilt. And we should, we need to admit that and we need to repent of that. And we need to respond to that. And when we do so, we find that God does forgive and God does redeem and God does restore. And that’s the beautiful thing of, that’s the good news is that we can’t fix things on our own. And yet God has provided all we need for life and godliness, and to be able to live lives that are free in Christ.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. You know, when you mentioned earlier that shame is essentially healed-anything that any relational shame is only basically kind of redeemed through relationship and on its own. And so it seems like a natural place that we would turn to would be our relationships, as well as the church. And yet we’re all fallen people and we know that friendships can be fraught. And the church being comprised of fallen people often has done perhaps a better job of shaming than at restoration and would be very interested in your thoughts about what are the characteristics either of a church or even just in our personal capacities as a friend who basically serves as a restorer, someone who contributes to restoration and the release of shame and the reminder of who we were created to be. What does that look like in real life?

TONI KIM:

Such a good question Cherie. This is, so first of all, for those who have been hurt by others have been hurt by the church, I’m deeply sorry for that. And I grieve with you. And Jesus understands that, right? Jesus was betrayed with a kiss by a friend. So he understands what it means to be betrayed. He understands the pain. He understands the betrayal that you have experienced. So first of all, know that you have a savior who has been there, who does understand, and who will make it so that this is not the ending of your story and not the defining part of your story. And so as Christians, I think we all need to remember that we ourselves have been saved by grace. And the more we remember that, the more we’re able to extend grace to one another. So often I think we ask God to judge our enemies, but to have mercy on us. And so the more we can learn to ask God to have mercy on us all will help us. So I think we need as God’s people to remember that it is God’s kindness that leads us to repentance. And so to show kindness to one another, to show grace and mercy to each other while we are still in process.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. You know, even though shame, relational shame can only be healed in relationship, one of the things I noted is that at the end of each of your chapters, you give verses that you encourage reflection on and memorization of. And, you know, presumably, I mean, there’s going to be some people and we hope there’ll be many of them who like read this book in community and in reading groups, but probably the majority of readers are people reading it on their own. What kind of role or impact do you believe that kind of more individualized and personal contemplative practices or scripture memorization? What role does that play in in redeeming shame?

TONI KIM:

Yeah, I was deeply formed by I became a Christian when I was in Texas, and there was a pastor in Texas who said, the word of God is, has to be so much a part of you that when you’re cut, you bleed Bible. And I think that’s so true. We have to hide God’s Word in our heart so that when we’re cut, what comes out of us is the Bible, is the truth of the word of God. But we have to be careful what we memorize because I mean, some of us, most of us know Romans 3:23 “for all of sin and fallen short of the glory of God.” But how many of us know that it’s followed immediately by “and all are justified freely by his grace through the redemption that came by Christ Jesus.” Like we just focus on, oh, we just, you know, again, this is a whole like, oh, we’re sinners. Like we’re all sinned and fallen short of the glory of God. But it’s also true that all have been justified freely by the grace that came through the redemption in Christ Jesus. And so, like, how do we let the Word of God really become a part of our identity, who we are. So that when we’re hurt that those truths ooze out of us to bring healing.

CHERIE HARDER:

Oh that’s beautiful. Well, I see many of the questions sort of piling up. And we’re going to turn to audience questions in just a second. But before we do so, I want to just ask you about, well, it’s the beautiful arc of the Bible that you spell out in the book. And it was in some ways a new lens to look at the biblical narrative in that, you know, you emphasize that at the very beginning in the garden, one of the first things it says about Adam and Eve was that they were naked and not ashamed. And then sin and shame, through shame, came into the garden. And, you know, and all that happens in between. And then the Bible ends with people standing confidently before God in a city. And in some ways, you’ve argued that the biblical narrative could actually be seen by some lights as God’s determination to rescue and restore people to be who he created them to be: unashamed, who no longer need to hide, who are connected to him and others. And so before we turn to audience questions, I would love for you just to kind of tell us a little bit more about what do you think this lens of reading scripture tells us both about human nature and about the heart of God?

TONI KIM:

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thank you. I think the heart of God is that he is so much more merciful than we believe him to be. He does not treat us as our sins deserve. So even in the Garden of Eden that he clothed Adam and Eve before he cast them out of the garden. And so there is, God does not treat Adam and Eve the way their sins deserve, and he does not treat us the way our sins deserve. And so yeah, the kindness of God is so much more generous than we dare to imagine most of the time.

CHERIE HARDER:

That’s great. So we’re going to turn to questions from our viewers right now. And if you are one of those brand new folks joining us for the first time, you can not only ask a question in the Q&A spot, but you can also like a question. And that helps give us an idea of what some of the more popular questions are. So we’ll start off with a question from Carla Hardy. And Carla asks, could you give more clarity on the differences and definition of what is guilt versus what is shame?

TONI KIM:

Thank you. I didn’t. Yeah. So and they are overlapping. But we can kind of separate them. So guilt has more to do with actions and individual actions. And it’s a forensic metaphor. And so if you are guilty of something and you’ve done something wrong, you expect punishment. And in order to be free from guilt, there has to be the forgiveness. That’s what heals guilt. Shame is more relational, even though it can be felt internally in an isolation. But shame has to do with your being, your whole sense of identity. So not just I did something wrong, but I am something wrong and that that’s what defines me. And so the fear with shame is exposure of rejection of isolation. And the healing is found in reconciliation and redemption. And so oftentimes they’re very, they’re experienced at the same time. But hopefully that helps a bit.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah, absolutely. And a question from Colin Tamakawa and Colin, apologies if I butchered your name. Okay. Well, Colin followed up on that by saying, do you have any suggestions or reflections on what kind of work the church needs to do to better equip ourselves to not just have a guilt worldview, but also include a shame worldview?

TONI KIM:

Yeah. Let’s reexamine the scriptures with that lens and you’ll find shame all over, and so help helping one another to name it, to be able to distinguish, hey, this is the guilt part of things, but there’s more that what scripture has to offer about the deeper struggles that people are feeling. So yeah, yeah, it does take.

CHERIE HARDER:

A question from Steve. Okay. A question from Steve Barrett and Steve says shame does seem to be cultural, relational, circumstantial, historical. Sometimes the church or our family might be more shame based than the larger culture. But you are leading us to find another person and or community to relate to in a healing way. Where do we look for this?

TONI KIM:

Yeah, I wish I could say it’s all over the church, but hopefully if we answer Colin’s question, then the church will become more and more the places where you can find this healing. So if you don’t have someone yet, I would pray and ask God, you know, can you lead me to someone and think about us getting involved in a local church and maybe in a small group and over time, building a relationship where you can feel the freedom to take a little bit of a risk to try this out. I mentioned Curt Thompson’s confessional communities. That’s something that you can look into and then get, is modeled across the the nation and across the world as well. But it does take us all kind of doing this together. The book does have a study guide at the end. And so you could as a small group go go through it together.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. So there’s a question from an anonymous attendee, sort of trying to dig in a little bit more about finding relationships. And they say to ask a shame person to find healing in a relationship or groups seems a little bit like asking a homeless person to solve their problem by buying a house. A shame person likely doesn’t have the resources of trusted friends or groups. How would you respond?

TONI KIM:

Again, I am grieved with you, for you and Jesus understands. So we start with Jesus. We start with saying to God, hey, you know what I’m going through. And you know what I can do. You know what I can’t do. And so I need your help. I need you to to bring someone in my life who will intervene and who will be this model of who you are to me. So start with that. And God is able to do beyond all that we ask or imagine.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. So another anonymous attendee says, I’m wondering what’s different about the role of shame in our culture now versus past generations and its effect on us today. We can see how unforgiving and pitiless our society now is to those in the public eye. How is that affecting even those of us who are just ordinary people? And what can we do as Christians to push back against this overwhelming tide?

TONI KIM:

Yeah. Yeah. Great question. Yeah. I think, we often talk about FOMO, the fear of missing out. But what this generation has is FOBFO, the fear of being found out. And this is a shame culture, right? Because so the, and social media has exacerbated that because we have to project this image of this picture perfect self. And we’re afraid of being found out for who we really are. We know that we actually have needs. We have limits. We’re afraid if we let people in a crack, they’ll just see the huge abyss of need that we have. So we’re afraid of those things. I think in past generations they understood we’re limited. And when we lived in community, there just was kind of this more understanding that we didn’t have to all be these superhuman people and in the church, these super Christians with so much faith that they can do all things through Christ who strengthens them, without understanding that what Christ gives us strength is to have plenty and to be in want. And so to know that we do, we need, we need one another to live this out.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. So a question from Emily Belvery and Emily asks over and over, scripture describes the results of salvation as “never being put to shame.” How would you describe what that means? She’s like, is this talking about our external state or our eternal state or our day to day experiences of shame or something else?

TONI KIM:

Yeah, that’s really a great question. And this is why shame is complex, right? Because the Psalms especially are full of these pleas: let me never be put to shame. And obviously Jesus experienced a lot of shame. And so how do we put these together? And so there are different kinds of shame. When as Christians, when we bear the name of Jesus, we have to be willing to experience shame before people, before others, in order to show our allegiance to Jesus. So there are different nuances to shame. So what I would say is that when we’re experiencing shame, that what we don’t want to do is to let shame isolate us. That’s what Satan wants us to do. And then instead we can cry out to God and say, do not let me be put to shame. We can echo the Psalms and we can echo that prayer and then let him kind of sort out, well, you know, what exactly does that look like in each situation?

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. That’s great. So a question from another anonymous attendee. A lot of people are going incognito it appears.

TONI KIM:

It’s hard to talk about shame publicly.

CHERIE HARDER:

And they’re asking, what is it in some cultures that leads them to be more shame based than others in a globalizing society and also church? How can churches navigate these cultural differences and varying views on shame with wisdom? A lot in that question.

TONI KIM:

Yeah. Sensitively, I think because shame is relational and relationship involves two people and they’re all going to, even if you’re from the same culture, there’s going to be nuances. So I think we just have to give each other the permission to be in process. And so the way my understanding of shame may differ from your cultural understanding, it’s not that mine is right and yours is wrong. It’s that mine brings this insight and yours brings that insight. And maybe over time, I’m going to learn, I’m going to become more like you and you’re going to be more like me. So let’s give each other the permission to be in process. There’s no shame about being in process and there’s no shame about having to learn from one another. And let’s give each other the freedom to say, let’s explore this together. So like, my understanding is different, but that doesn’t mean that one is right and one is wrong and one is good and one is evil. What can we learn from, from each other? And if we were all to be doing that, we would create a culture that is, again, one of more kindness than of shameless shaming of each other.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. So a question from Rochelle Aparam and Rochelle asks, can you explain the difference between being shamed by others e.g. what Jesus experienced and actually just feeling shame within oneself?

TONI KIM:

I think often they’re related because of things that people have said to us or done to us that we then internalize. I think oftentimes the shame we experience ourselves has less to do with sin itself. So I think oftentimes we feel shame about the color of our skin, our gender, things that we can’t actually repent of. And so when I talk about shame being complex, when we have shame about things, shame within ourselves, that we can’t solve by repenting, that’s the kind of shame that we again, bring to God to say like, I need not forgiveness, I need you to redeem my shame. I need you to convince me that the most true thing about me is that I’m your beloved child. And so this, the solution to the shame we feel inside is still this relational relating to God and relating to his people. So finding healing through his scriptures, his spirit and his saints.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. And so a question from another anonymous attendee who asks, are there places in people’s lives that you see shame quietly shaping their actions, how they view themselves or how they view God that we or they may not realize is based in shame.

TONI KIM:

Yeah, I think shame is incredibly insidious. And like I said, even for myself, I had no idea I would, I would be ashamed of having a daughter with down syndrome until it actually happened to me. And so I think it’s so insidious. But again, God is gracious to help us to weed these things out. And if we can help each other to not be ashamed of our shame, and to, you know, when the shame is there, to address it, bring it to light. And then have God’s word be the final word about our identity of who we are.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. So a question from Jason Glenn, who asks, do you believe that it’s right for Christians to ever use shame to shame people in an appropriate way for an appropriate cause?

TONI KIM:

Yeah. I mean, the apostle Paul, there’s one time where he says, I don’t say this to shame this, and then he says, I do say this to shame you. So I think it can be appropriate for Christians to use shame sometimes, but very, very big caveat because most of us are swimming in shame already. And so most of the times to shame someone is not the most effective thing for a Christian to do. So you can confront somebody, and you should when you have the appropriate relationship to do so, but anytime you confront someone about their sin, there should always be emphasis on where forgiveness is, where redemption is, where restoration is. And so we have to be very careful in how we use, use shame because we want-the goal needs to be redemption and restoration.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. A question from another anonymous attendee who says, I have a friend who has shame about a situation that she’s in through no fault of her own. How can I best minister to her when shame makes her feel defensive about even talking about the situation? I think she’s expecting judgment where I genuinely have none.

TONI KIM:

Yeah. Yeah. First of all, let me just say about all these anonymous posts, thank you for coming to this conversation and being, you know, bold enough to do that because it is, it’s so hard to talk about shame and what a great question. What a great, it shows shows your real heart for your friend. And it goes back to the question the other person asked before, like, if a person is feeling shame, like we can’t go and buy a house as a homeless person. And so you’re the answer to that other person’s question. This friend who wants to go and approach. And I think we should start by saying, I was just listening to this podcast and, and reminded about the shame that Jesus experienced that was no fault of his own. And just kind of tell that story of someone who does understand what it is to experience shame for which he had no blame and how that shame that he endured is not the end of his story and is, and the shame that your friend has experienced is not the end of his or her story.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah, we’ll try to fit in one last question. Also from an anonymous attendee asking, wondering about your thoughts on the idea that narcissism is the inability to metabolize shame and how our culture may reflect this as well.

TONI KIM:

Yeah, yeah, I think that so much of when you have appropriate shame, then you do struggle with imposter syndrome, right? There’s this disconnect between who you are projected to be and who you actually are. And I think the one category of people who doesn’t struggle with imposter syndrome is narcissists because and they’re the ones that should be struggling with imposter syndrome because who they project and who they are are not good. And so yeah, I do think there is a very big problem of narcissists not being able to understand that they should have shame they should, and they need to address their shame issues.

CHERIE HARDER:

Yeah. Toni, it’s been so much fun to talk with you. And in just a moment, I want to give you the last word, but before that, there’s a few things to share with all of you who are watching. First, immediately after we conclude, we’ll be sending around an online feedback form. I say this every time, but we really appreciate it when you fill this out. We read all of these. We do try to incorporate your suggestions and as a small token of appreciation for doing so, we will send you a code for a free Trinity Forum reading download of your choice. There are a number of our readings that go more deeply into some of the topics that we’ve discussed, and a few we would recommend include Augustine’s Confessions, Purchase of a Soul by Victor Hugo, The Long Loneliness by Dorothy Day, and Wrestling with God by Simone Vey. In addition to everyone who registered, we’ll be sending around an email tomorrow with a link to a lightly edited video, today’s online conversation, along with a whole list of readings and resources if you want to go more deeply into the topic. So be on the lookout and please feel free, you’re warmly welcome to share this conversation with others, to start your own conversation about what shame redeemed might look like. In addition, I wanted to invite all of you who are watching to join the Trinity Forum Society, which is the community of people who together advance Trinity Forum’s mission of cultivating, curating, and communicating the best of Christian thought for the common good.

CHERIE HARDER:

In addition to being part of that community and part of that mission, there’s a whole variety of benefits to being a member of the Trinity Forum, including a subscription to our quarterly Trinity Forum readings, a subscription to our daily What We’re reading list of curated reading recommendations, and as a special incentive for all new members, or with your gift of $150 or more, we will send you a signed copy of Toni Kim’s excellent new book, Shame Redeemed. So we would love to welcome you into the society and hope that you will avail yourself of that opportunity. In addition, stay tuned for new online conversations announcements coming up soon. And also just a reminder that you can also, if you missed an online conversation, you can listen to it as a podcast as well as watch it on YouTube. So Trinity Forum conversations podcast is available on Spotify or anywhere else you get your podcast and we would love for you to like and subscribe. As we near the end of our time together, I want to give big thanks and a shout out to the Trinity Forum team. They may not be in front of the camera, but they really help make all of the work and the mission of the Trinity Forum happen. So big thanks to Tom Walsh, Campbell Vogel, Marie-Anne Morris, Robin Dixon, and Jack Anderson. Really appreciate each and every one of you. And finally, as promised, Toni, I want to give the last word to you.

TONI KIM:

And I want to give the last word to 1 John 3:1. See what great love the father has lavished on us that we should be called children of God and that is what we are. Go knowing that you are a beloved child of God.

CHERIE HARDER:

Toni, thank you so much. It’s been great to talk with you.

TONI KIM:

It’s been a joy, thank you so much.

CHERIE HARDER:

Thank you to each of you for joining us. Have a great weekend.

SHARE

More Events